Someone Else at the Table
I.You’ve seen it happen
You know the moment. Dinner is going fine. Somebody is telling the story everyone has heard before, and people are laughing anyway. Then a name comes up, or something from the news, and the room changes. Voices go flat, or sharp. Somebody gets up to check on the pie. The person you were laughing with a minute ago is gone, and someone else is sitting in their chair.
Maybe you’ve been the someone else. I have. Maybe you stopped going to that kind of dinner. Maybe you go and keep quiet, or you decided a while back that the whole business is rotten and the only sane thing left is to stop looking at it. If that’s where you are, I won’t try to talk you out of being tired. You’ve earned it.
This piece is about that someone else. I’ve come to believe three things about them. They aren’t who any of us are. A great many people make their living by keeping them in the chair. And they can be asked, gently, to leave. Nobody has to end up agreeing for that to happen. People can learn to talk to each other again, and the evidence for it is better than the news would lead you to think.
II.The table I grew up at
When I was a kid we spent the holidays at my grandparents’ house. It was a full house and a happy one. These were people who didn’t see each other often enough, and you could tell how glad they were to be in the same room.
Every year, at some point in the day, politics found its way in.
Nobody shouted. They always kept it civil enough. But even a kid could feel it from across the room. People who had been teasing each other an hour earlier went stiff and careful. Their voices changed, and so did their faces. I didn’t understand what they were arguing about, and I think that’s why I saw it so clearly. With nothing to follow in the argument, all I had to watch was the change.
It was one of the strangest things I’d ever seen. These were people who loved each other and had been having a good time, and in the space of a minute something had turned them into different people. I remember watching their faces and wondering where they had gone.
III.Then it got me
I paid no attention to politics until my mid-twenties. Then I formed some opinions, and almost at once I was doing the thing I’d watched as a kid. Someone would say something I disagreed with, and I’d react before I’d had time to think. I argued with people I love. I believed the issues mattered too much not to fight for, and I still think they matter that much.
That phase didn’t last long. I started to notice my own reactions, and I didn’t like how they felt, or who I was while I was having them. It took longer to see the other problem, which was that it didn’t work. Going at people that way was never going to change anyone’s mind.
So I quit arguing. For a long stretch after that I kept my views to myself and talked about them only with people who already shared them. That’s more comfortable than fighting. It also means the only account of the other side you ever hear comes from your own. Then came a period when I wanted to ignore all of it.
I’ve fought, I’ve kept to my own, and I’ve looked away. I’d guess most people have done at least one of those. Each is a way of getting clear of that feeling at the table, and I understand all three. But the problems in front of us are enormous, and half the country isn’t going to solve them without the other half. If we’re going to get through this, it has to be possible for anyone to talk with anyone.
IV.The mask
The Romans called the mask an actor wore a persona. It’s where our word person comes from. The actor spoke through it, and it gave him one fixed expression that could be read from the back row. Behind it, the actor was still there.
That’s the nearest thing I’ve found to what I watched as a kid. When politics came up, the people at that table put on masks. Each mask had one expression and one voice, and each was built to be read from a distance, by the people on its own side. And the mask did the talking.
The Buddha described the same thing 2,500 years ago. Most people know the story of the blind men and the elephant. Fewer know why he told it. Teachers from rival schools had gathered in the city of Savatthi and were quarreling, each insisting that his teaching alone was true. So the Buddha told of a king who had all the city’s blind men led to an elephant, each to a different part. The man who felt the ear said an elephant is like a winnowing basket. The one who felt the tusk said a plowshare. The leg was a pillar, and the tuft of the tail a broom. Then they fought each other with their fists. The Buddha’s verdict on the quarreling teachers, in an old translation, is that they were “perceiving only one side of a case.”
Nobody in the story is lying. Each man is right about the part he’s holding. As I read it, the fight starts when he takes his part for the whole animal, and then takes it for himself, so that a challenge to his view feels like an attack on him. Buddhist teaching has a name for that grip. It’s called clinging to views, and it’s counted among the basic kinds of clinging, alongside clinging to pleasure. The teaching doesn’t ask anyone to have no views. The trouble is in the clinging.
It took me years to see what’s under the grip. Nobody goes stiff over something they don’t care about. Look behind any of those masks, mine included, and you find a person who is afraid for something they love: their kids, their country, their sense of what’s right, the world they thought they were handing on. I’ve come to think the someone else at the table is what love looks like when it’s scared.
That changed how the memory looks to me. I used to see a happy family interrupted by something ugly. Now I see people who cared so much that they couldn’t stay in their own faces. There’s something almost beautiful in it, and it’s terribly sad, because the fear comes out aimed at the very people they love, who are sitting three feet away and afraid for the same things.
V.Who it’s good for
For a long time I resisted the next part, because it sounds like something a crank would say. The someone else at the table is useful to people, and they know it.
On May 21, 2016, two groups of protesters faced each other across a street in downtown Houston, outside an Islamic center. One side had come to a rally called “Stop Islamization of Texas.” The other had come to “Save Islamic Knowledge.” They shouted at each other, and the local news covered it. A year and a half later, the Republican chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee told the country what neither side had known. Both rallies had been advertised by Facebook pages run from the same office in St. Petersburg, Russia. The whole thing had cost about two hundred dollars in ads.
Some of the counter-protesters say they would have come anyway, and I believe them. The anger on that street was real on both sides. That’s why it was worth two hundred dollars. Nobody had to invent the division. They only had to bring both halves of it to the same corner.
If a foreign government thinks our fighting each other is worth paying for, it’s fair to ask who else finds it useful.
Start with the screens. In 2018, Facebook’s own researchers told the company’s executives that its algorithms “exploit the human brain’s attraction to divisiveness,” according to internal documents reported by the Wall Street Journal. The Journal reported that the executives largely shelved the work; Facebook disputed that account. A few years later, researchers went through 2.7 million posts from news outlets and members of Congress and found that posts about the other side were shared about twice as often as posts about one’s own. That study can’t prove what causes what. But anyone whose living depends on attention can read the chart.
Then the politicians. Open a fundraising email from either party and count the sentences about the other one. Lyndon Johnson knew the trick from the inside. In 1960, looking at racist signs along a road in Tennessee, he told a young aide what was at the bottom of them: if you can convince the poorest white man that he’s better than any Black man, “he won’t notice you’re picking his pocket.”
A small, current example shows what it costs us. For years, close to nine in ten Americans have told pollsters that members of Congress shouldn’t be allowed to trade stocks. In a University of Maryland survey, that was 87 percent of Republicans and 88 percent of Democrats. There aren’t many things nine in ten of us agree on. This summer the House finally passed a version of it, with a voter ID requirement attached that had nothing to do with stocks. In September it died in the Senate, 53 to 47, on a straight party-line vote. Each party says the other one killed it. They may both be right. What I notice is how it died. Something nearly all of us want got tied to something we’ve been trained to fight about, and that was the end of it.
I don’t think it takes a secret meeting. Outrage pays, in money and attention and votes, and nobody who is paid by it has a reason to turn it off. The result is the same as if it had been planned. A divided people is easy to manage, because it can be counted on to spend its strength on itself. A people who can talk to each other are another matter. They can find the things nine in ten of them want, and insist.
The old stories knew this. Aesop has a father hand his quarreling sons a bundle of sticks and ask them to break it. They can’t. Then he unties the bundle and hands them the sticks one at a time. And Jesus, answering his accusers, gave the line Lincoln later borrowed: “if a house be divided against itself, that house cannot stand.”
So when the someone else sits down at your table, it helps to remember that they didn’t come alone. A great deal of money and skill went into sending them. That doesn’t excuse any of us. But it changed how I feel about the person in the chair. It’s hard to stay angry at someone once you see that the two of you are being played off each other.
VI.If you’ve given up
Maybe your road has been longer than mine. Maybe you cared a great deal once. Over the years you may have come to lean the way the people around you leaned, without ever quite deciding to. At some point you concluded that they’re all liars. You narrowed down to the few voices you still trusted, and eventually you let most of those go too. Where you’ve landed is that it’s hopeless, and that the kindest thing you can do for yourself is not look.
I don’t think you were foolish at any step of that. “They’re all liars” is a fair review of much of what’s on offer, and looking away is real rest.
But look at what “hopeless” is about. It’s about the politicians, the parties and the people on the screens. It was never a verdict on your brother-in-law, or on the neighbor with the yard sign. Somewhere along the way the two got welded together, and the hopelessness you feel about the first spread to the second. I’d say that’s no accident either. People who have given up on each other are as easy to manage as people who are fighting.
The screens leave something out. In 2018 a research group called More in Common surveyed 8,000 Americans and found that about two-thirds of us belong to what they named the exhausted majority: people worn out by the fighting who mostly aren’t part of it. Three in four said our differences aren’t so great that we can’t come together. In a second study, the group asked Democrats and Republicans to guess how many people on the other side hold extreme views. Both sides guessed more than half. The real figure was about three in ten. And the people who followed the news most closely were off by nearly three times as much as people who followed it only now and then.
It hasn’t always been this way, either. In 1960, pollsters asked Americans how they’d feel if their son or daughter married someone from the other party. About one in twenty said they’d be displeased. By 2010, when a similar question was asked, about half of Republicans and a third of Democrats said they’d be unhappy about it. Something that grows that much in fifty years isn’t simply human nature. It was learned, and what’s learned can be unlearned.
If you’re tired, you aren’t the odd one out. You’re in the majority. The third at the edges gets the airtime, and the airtime is where most of our picture of each other comes from.
VII.What loosens it
In 2016, in South Florida, 56 canvassers knocked on the doors of about 500 voters to talk about prejudice against transgender people, about as charged a subject as there is. They didn’t argue. They asked the person at the door about a time they themselves had been judged for being different, and then they listened. Each conversation ran about ten minutes. Researchers followed up with those voters, and three months later their attitudes had still shifted.
The same researchers ran larger studies in the years that followed, with nearly 7,000 voters in seven places, and they’re careful about what they found. The changes were small. They lasted at least four months. And when canvassers only made arguments, however good, nothing happened at all. What moved people was being asked for their own story and having it heard without judgment.
It changed the people doing the knocking, too. In a later study, activists who spent their days listening to voters on the other side came away feeling warmer toward them. It’s hard to hear someone’s story for ten minutes and go on seeing a mask.
Other researchers have tried simply showing people the truth about the other side. In one study, Americans guessed that their political opponents supported violence at several times the real rate. When they were shown the actual numbers, their own support for violence dropped by about a third, and it was still lower a month later. In the largest test so far, 32,000 people were each given one of 25 short exercises. Twenty-three of the exercises reduced dislike of the other side. The ones that worked best showed ordinary, likable people from across the line, or reminded people of what they share.
None of this is a cure. In nearly every one of these studies the effect faded over weeks or months once the exercise was over. The researchers also warn that feeling warmer toward the other side doesn’t, by itself, change what people will put up with from their own side in order to win. Warmth is a beginning.
I don’t find the fading discouraging. We rehearse the mask every day, every time we pick up a phone. It makes sense that taking it off takes practice too, and practice is something the old traditions understand.
A Buddhist meditation manual from the fifth century, still in use, teaches loving-kindness as a sequence. You begin by wishing yourself well. Then you wish it for someone you respect, then for a dear friend, then for a person you have no feelings about either way. Only after all of that do you turn to someone who is hostile to you, and you keep at it until you can wish every one of them well without preferring one over another. The manual is firm about the order. Don’t start with the hostile person, it says, because anger is what will come up.
I used to practice this a lot. During the years when I meditated regularly, I used a recording of Ram Dass guiding it, step by step, in the same order. At the time there was someone who had been a hard presence in my family’s life for years, and I felt deeply wronged by him. The person at the end of the sequence, the one you face and wish peace, was always him.
What I didn’t expect was how much peace it brought me. Everything I had been carrying toward him had no effect on him at all. It only weighed on me. Wishing him well was a way of putting that down, for my own sake as much as his. It’s a powerful thing to do.
Jesus put the whole sequence into three words: love your enemies. I used to hear that as an impossible demand. I hear it now as a description of where the practice ends up, for anyone who keeps at it. He was talking to people who had real enemies, and he said it anyway.
VIII.This year’s table
Ram Dass is often quoted as saying that if you think you’re enlightened, you should go spend a week with your family. The holidays are coming, and most of us are about to take that test. This is what I take from everything above for the day itself.
Watch for the mask in yourself first. It arrives before any thought does, as a tightening, with the reply already forming. You can’t stop it from arriving. You can notice it, and noticing is most of the practice. Noticing my own reactions is what got me out of the arguing years.
Remember what’s under theirs. When someone across the table goes stiff, they’re afraid for something they love. You don’t have to agree with them to see that, and it’s hard to hate someone while you’re seeing it.
You don’t have to win, and nothing has to be settled by dessert. Remember what the door-knockers found. Arguments by themselves changed nothing.
Ask for the story behind the position. “What happened that made you see it that way?” is a different question from “How can you think that?” Then listen to the answer as if you’ll be asked to repeat it.
Don’t start with the hardest person. The old manual is right about this. Sit next to someone easy. Wish the difficult one well from across the room before you try it up close.
Setting a subject down isn’t giving up on a person. If it gets hot, go check on the pie. You can pick the subject up another day, or never. The dinner matters more than the topic.
This site takes its name from an idea of Terence McKenna’s: that a sick society, like a sick body, makes antibodies, and that the antibodies are people. I used to picture something grand when I read that. At a holiday table it’s a small job. It’s the one person who feels the mask coming and leaves it off. A room takes its cue from somebody. It might as well be you.
IX.They came back
There’s one more thing about my grandparents’ table, and I didn’t see what it meant until I was grown. The shift never won. The subject would change and the day would go on, and the next holiday everyone was back at the same table, glad to see each other. Year after year the masks went on for an hour, and year after year the people behind them came back. Whatever sat down in their chairs for that hour wasn’t them, and it didn’t get to keep them.
In 1958 a Trappist monk named Thomas Merton was running an errand in Louisville. At the corner of Fourth and Walnut, in a downtown crowd of shoppers he had never met, something gave way in him. He found that he loved every one of those strangers, and that the wall he had always assumed stood between himself and other people had never been there. He later described the people on that corner as “walking around shining like the sun,” and said he knew of no way to make them see it.
That is what’s behind the mask at your table. I can’t promise you anything about the people on the screens. The people at the table are another matter. Most of them are as tired as you are. They are who this country is made of, and almost none of them are who they turn into for that hour. Ram Dass had a line for what we’re doing here with each other: we’re all just walking each other home.
So this year, when someone at your table turns into someone else, you’ll know what you’re looking at. It may be you. Notice it, remember what they’re afraid for, pass the potatoes, and wait. The person you love is still in there, and they come back.
A note on process: the ideas, the direction and the lived experience here are mine. I write these with Claude, an AI model, for research, structure and drafting, and I read and sign off on every piece. More on the About page.
- M. Keith Chen and Ryne Rohla, “The effect of partisanship and political advertising on close family ties,” Science 360 (2018): 1020–1024.
- Shanto Iyengar, Gaurav Sood and Yphtach Lelkes, “Affect, Not Ideology,” Public Opinion Quarterly 76 (2012): 405–431.
- U.S. Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, hearing on social media influence in the 2016 elections, November 1, 2017; and the Committee’s report, Russian Active Measures Campaigns and Interference in the 2016 U.S. Election, vol. 2 (2019).
- Jeff Horwitz and Deepa Seetharaman, “Facebook Executives Shut Down Efforts to Make the Site Less Divisive,” The Wall Street Journal, May 26, 2020.
- Steve Rathje, Jay Van Bavel and Sander van der Linden, “Out-group animosity drives engagement on social media,” PNAS 118 (2021).
- Bill Moyers, “What a Real President Was Like,” The Washington Post, November 13, 1988.
- Program for Public Consultation, University of Maryland, “Americans on Stock Trading by Members of Congress” (2023). H.R. 7008, 119th Congress: House roll call, July 22, 2026; Senate roll call vote 253, September 30, 2026.
- More in Common, Hidden Tribes (2018) and The Perception Gap (2019).
- David Broockman and Joshua Kalla, “Durably reducing transphobia,” Science 352 (2016): 220–224; Kalla and Broockman, American Political Science Review 114 (2020): 410–425 and 116 (2022): 1516–1522.
- Joseph Mernyk et al., “Correcting inaccurate metaperceptions reduces Americans’ support for partisan violence,” PNAS 119 (2022).
- Jan Voelkel et al., “Megastudy testing 25 treatments to reduce antidemocratic attitudes and partisan animosity,” Science 386 (2024).
- The Udāna, 6.4, trans. D. M. Strong (1902).
- Buddhaghosa, The Path of Purification (Visuddhimagga), ch. IX, trans. Bhikkhu Ñāṇamoli.
- Mark 3:25 and Matthew 5:44, King James Version. Aesop, “The Bundle of Sticks.”
- Thomas Merton, Conjectures of a Guilty Bystander (1966).
More from Love Everybody, Tell the Truth